Adjudicate
Now
Claim defence

Excavator hire dispute: testing the basis of the claim

A response to a hire-cost claim focused on the agreed equipment, site suitability and the work actually performed.

Defence preparedOutcome: We challenged the hire charges after a 25-tonne excavator was supplied in place of the agreed 14-tonne machine.

Act and time limits

The recorded step was a response to a payment demand. For an application concerning plant hire on your project, select the jurisdiction below.

Queensland

Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld) · ss 76 and 79(2)(b)

  • Lower scheduled amount. Apply within 30 business days after receiving the payment schedule.
  • Scheduled amount unpaid. Apply within 20 business days after the payment due date.
  • No schedule and the claim was not paid in full. Apply within 30 business days after the later of the payment due date and the last day for giving a schedule. The schedule period is 15 business days after the respondent receives the claim, or the shorter period in the contract.

Read the Act

New South Wales

Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) · s 17(2), (3)(c)–(e)

  • Lower scheduled amount. Apply within 10 business days after receiving the payment schedule.
  • Scheduled amount unpaid. Apply within 20 business days after the payment due date.
  • No schedule and the claim was not paid in full. Serve the notice of intention to apply within 20 business days after the payment due date. Allow 5 business days after the respondent receives the notice to provide a schedule, then apply within 10 business days after that period ends.

Read the Act

Victoria

Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2002 (Vic) · s 18(2), (3)(c)–(e)

  • Lower scheduled amount. Apply within 10 business days after receiving the payment schedule.
  • Scheduled amount unpaid. Apply within 10 business days after the payment due date.
  • No schedule and the claim was not paid in full. Give the notice of intention within 10 business days after the payment due date. Allow 5 business days from receipt for a schedule, then lodge within 5 business days after that period ends.
  • These periods are for payment claims under the amended scheme from 15 April 2026. Earlier claims can fall under the transitional rules.

Read the Act

Western Australia

Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2021 (WA) · s 28(1)–(4)

  • Contracts entered into on or after 1 August 2022. Apply within 20 business days after first becoming entitled to apply. A schedule for less than the amount claimed and failure to pay by the due date are distinct triggers.
  • No schedule and payment is overdue. Give written notice of intention within 20 business days after the payment due date. Allow 5 business days from receipt for a schedule before using the no-schedule route.
  • For contracts entered into before 1 August 2022, the Construction Contracts (Former Provisions) Act 2004 (WA), s 26(1), ordinarily requires an application within 90 business days after the payment dispute arises.

Read the Act

Northern Territory

Construction Contracts (Security of Payments) Act 2004 (NT) · ss 8, 10A and 28(1), (3)

  • For a payment dispute under Part 3, prepare and serve the application on the other contracting parties and the appropriate adjudicator or prescribed appointer within 65 working days after the dispute arises. The count starts the next day.
  • Identify the dispute under s 8 from the claim, the contract and the payment or rejection record. A qualifying high-value contract may provide a different adjudication process under s 10A.

Read the Act

A large excavator beside a constrained road excavation at dusk — illustrative image
AI-generated illustration of the case-study subject.

On 18 September 2021, we prepared a response disputing a demand for excavator hire charges. The dispute concerned what equipment had been agreed, what arrived on site and whether the charges claimed were justified.

The site circumstances

The client's position was that a 14-tonne excavator had been agreed, but a 25-tonne machine arrived and was too large for the excavation. The crew had not been inducted. Traffic detours and police arrangements were in place for the night works, yet the planned stormwater trench excavation did not proceed.

The response

We challenged the suggestion that allowing the alternative machine onto the site entitled the supplier to the charges. We compared the equipment ordered with the machine supplied and showed that the planned excavation did not proceed.

The outcome

We disputed the hire charges on the basis of the agreed equipment and the work actually performed.

What the preparation demonstrates

A response to plant hire charges needs the agreed scope, dispatch and attendance records, induction records and evidence of the work performed. Those records allow the response to address individual charges and the contractual basis for them.

Explore related experience

Put the evidence to work.

Tell us about the project, the disputed amount and any approaching deadline.

Discuss your claim →